Drinkolipopstore

For soda lovers making the switch to gut-healthy alternatives, few decisions are as pivotal as choosing your cola. Olipop has masterfully reimagined two of the most beloved soda profiles: the smooth, retro-inspired Vintage Cola and the fruity, bold Cherry Cola. But which one deserves a spot in your fridge? In this deep dive, we compare taste, ingredients, nutrition, and versatility to help you decide. Whether you're a purist or a cherry-forward fan, this review will guide you to your perfect prebiotic cola.

What Makes These Colas Different? Flavor Profiles at a Glance

Before we get into the nitty-gritty, let's define the core personality of each can.

Olipop Vintage Cola is designed to evoke the classic cola experience. Think the nostalgic blend of vanilla, cinnamon, and citrus notes—without the high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors. It's familiar yet cleaner, with a light carbonation that doesn't overwhelm. Fans describe it as a “grown-up” cola that pairs perfectly with a burger or a quiet afternoon.

Olipop Cherry Cola, meanwhile, takes that classic base and adds a layer of tart-sweet cherry. The cherry is not medicinal or candy-like; it's a natural, slightly tangy note that brightens the cola's depth. It's bolder, fruitier, and leans into the nostalgic territory of cherry sodas from your childhood—only with 9 grams of fiber and just 2 grams of sugar.

Both flavors belong to Olipop's core lineup, but they serve different cravings. If you're looking for a versatile daily sipper, Vintage Cola is the safe bet. If you want something that stands out in a glass of ice or a cocktail, Cherry Cola brings the drama.

Ingredients Showdown: What's Inside Each Can?

Both colas are built on Olipop's signature prebiotic fiber blend (chicory root, cassava root, and other plant fibers), but their botanical and flavor profiles diverge. Let's break it down.

Vintage Cola Ingredients

• Purified water
• Olipop's prebiotic fiber blend (chicory root, cassava root, tapioca, etc.)
• Natural flavors (including vanilla, cinnamon, and citrus extracts)
• Apple cider vinegar (for digestive support)
• Stevia leaf extract
• Citric acid
• Potassium citrate
• Sea salt

Cherry Cola Ingredients

• Purified water
• Same prebiotic fiber blend
• Natural flavors (cherry, vanilla, and cola extracts)
• Apple cider vinegar
• Stevia leaf extract
• Citric acid
• Potassium citrate
• Sea salt
• Beta-carotene (for color)

Notice that Cherry Cola adds a touch of beta-carotene for its ruby hue, while Vintage Cola relies on a caramel-like natural coloring. Both are free from artificial dyes. The apple cider vinegar in both provides a subtle tang that enhances the cola's complexity without being sour.

Nutritional Comparison: More Alike Than Different

Per 12 oz can	Vintage Cola	Cherry Cola
Calories	35	35
Total Fat	0g	0g
Sodium	15mg	20mg
Total Carbohydrate	10g	10g
Dietary Fiber	9g	9g
Total Sugars	2g	2g
Added Sugars	0g	0g
Protein	1g	1g

As you can see, the nutrition panels are virtually identical. Both deliver 9 grams of prebiotic fiber per can—35% of the daily recommended intake—and only 2 grams of naturally occurring sugar. The slight sodium difference is negligible. So your choice really comes down to flavor preference, not health edge.

Taste Test: The Blind Sip-by-Sip Experience

We conducted a blind taste test with five Olipop fans (including two who were new to prebiotic sodas). Here's what we found.

Vintage Cola

On first sip, the vanilla and cinnamon notes are immediately present. It's smooth, with a gentle spice that lingers. The carbonation is moderate—not as aggressive as a mainstream cola, but satisfying. Testers described it as “reminiscent of a classic fountain cola but cleaner” and “less syrupy.” One tester noted a slight herbal finish from the chicory root, but it was subtle. It pairs beautifully with salty snacks or on its own over ice.

Cherry Cola

The cherry flavor hits upfront—bright and tart, like real cherry juice rather than candy. Then the cola base emerges, blending with the cherry for a balanced finish. Testers who loved cherry sodas were thrilled, while those who prefer a purist cola found it slightly sweet. The cherry note adds complexity that works well in mocktails or as a standalone treat. One tester said, “It's like a cherry cola from a soda fountain, but without the sugar crash later.”

Overall Winner (Taste Only)

It was a split decision: 3 out of 5 preferred Vintage Cola for its versatility, while 2 chose Cherry Cola for its boldness. If you love classic cola, go Vintage. If you want a fruity twist, go Cherry.

Pairing and Versatility: Which Cola Works Best Where?

Both colas shine in different contexts. Here's how to use them:

• Vintage Cola: Perfect for daily sipping, mixing in cocktails (try it with bourbon or rum), or pairing with burgers, pizza, or grilled meats. Its neutral profile makes it a kitchen staple.
• Cherry Cola: Ideal for mocktails (add lime and mint), as a dessert soda (pair with vanilla ice cream for a float), or for those who crave a fruit-forward soda. It also makes a great base for a prebiotic Cherry Coke float.

For a family-friendly option, consider adding the Favorites Variety Pack to your cart. It includes both Vintage Cola and Cherry Cola, plus other top flavors like Classic Grape and Ginger Ale, so everyone gets their favorite.

Price and Availability

Both flavors are priced identically at Drinkolipopstore and are available individually or in multipacks. You can also find them in curated variety packs. Because they're core flavors, they're rarely out of stock—unlike seasonal limited-edition releases. If you're new to Olipop, buying a single can of each is a low-risk way to decide.

Final Verdict: Which Olipop Cola Should You Buy?

After this deep dive, the answer is clear: it depends on your palate. Vintage Cola is the ultimate classic cola—smooth, balanced, and endlessly versatile. It's the cola you can drink every day without getting bored. Cherry Cola is the exciting sibling—bolder, fruitier, and perfect for when you want something with a little more personality.

For the best of both worlds, we recommend the Favorites Variety Pack, which lets you sample both colas along with other fan-favorites. That way, you can decide which one becomes your go-to—or keep both on hand for different cravings.

Why Choose Prebiotic Cola Over Traditional Soda?

Beyond taste, both Olipop colas offer serious health benefits. With 9 grams of prebiotic fiber per can, they feed your gut microbiome, support regularity, and help you avoid the blood sugar spikes associated with regular soda. They're also free from artificial sweeteners, preservatives, and high fructose corn syrup. For anyone looking to reduce sugar without sacrificing flavor, these colas are a game-changer.

Whether you're a cola purist or a cherry fanatic, Olipop has a can waiting for you. Ready to find your favorite? Explore the full lineup and grab a few cans today.